Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death and Hope in a Mumbai Slum

katharine_boo.jpg
Image Source: 
Courtsey Amazon

 

 

Behind the Beautiful Forevers Life, Death and Hope in a Mumbai Slum

Katherine Boo

Portobello Books, London, 2012, Kindle Edition

Reviewed by: Gopa Roy

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thu, 2013-02-07

 In the Author’s note with which the book concludes, Katherine Boo reflects ‘...over the course of three years  [2008-2011] (we) wrestled with the question of whether days in rat-filled Annawadi garbage sheds and late-night expeditions with thieves at a glamorous new airport had anything to contribute to an understanding of the pursuit of opportunity in an unequal, globalized world.  Maybe, we concluded.’ (p. 252)

My book group met this week as usual in one of our North London homes to discuss this, our first book of 2013.  It had served as ‘an antidote to Christmas’, commented one of my friends. We had found it compelling and painful.  We are not often unanimous about a book, but this was one of those rare instances.  Indeed, not only did we feel, without exception, that we were glad to have read it, we agreed that it is essential reading. Why?  Boo enables her readers to enter a world which is otherwise inaccessible to us – as it is to the better-off  inhabitants of Mumbai, the dwellers in the ‘overcity’ – a world it is important that we should understand.  She accomplishes this with an authority which enables us to trust what she reports. ‘The account of the hours leading up to  Fatima Shaikh’s self-immolation, and its immediate aftermath, derives from repeated interviews of 168 people, as well as records from the police department, the public hospital, the morgue, and the courts (p.252)
 
Her method restores the voices and experiences of the people whose lives she records, where the official records have demonstrably been changed and corrupted to suit the purposes of officialdom. True, the work is not straightforward documentary, the material is not presented chronologically.  It is a skilfully structured narrative which keeps us reading partly because we want to know the outcome – are the wrongfully accused justified in the faith they have in the judiciary, or will they be returned to the desperate conditions of the prisons which they have already experienced?  Even freedom in a slum such as Annawadi is preferable. There is an anticipation of this near the beginning of the book, when Abdul, the expert young sorter of waste thinks about his work, ‘work more boring than dirty.  Work he expected to be doing for the rest of his life.  Most days, that prospect weighed on him like a sentence.  Tonight, hiding from the police, it felt like hope’. (loc. 100)
 
The book is not political in a heavy-handed way, but it does demonstrate very clearly the devastating consequences of inequality and the repercussions felt by those whose lives Boo follows, of shifting economic sands in the wider world.  It shows us why people leave their villages and do not want to return (life is even harder there, though it need not be); why Maoists are rural India’s problem and why religious militants the urban hazard; why we should think about the waste we produce or where we send and spend our money.
Our reading of the book happened to coincide with the rape in Delhi and the period that followed.  It confirmed in many ways – and in soberingly matter-of-fact ways – the inequalities and attitudes highlighted by the rape and reactions to it. In Annawadi fathers avoid leaving their young daughters alone because they risk violation by drunken men or police. The judge in the court case happens to be a woman, but this is not commented on by anyone.  Nevertheless life for a woman in the slum is preferable to life in a village.  One of the saddest figures in the book is that of Meena, who is not just a girl, she has a brutal family who beat her at every opportunity. ‘The minutes in the night stench [of the toilets] with Manju were the closest she had ever come to freedom’ (p.185)
 
A marriage is arranged for her which will return her to the village.  There, as a Dalit, she will be relegated to the outskirts of the village. ‘What if over the verge of marriage stretched an adult life even more confined than her childhood had been? To both Meena and Manju, marrying into a village family was like time-travelling backward . . . Those villagers would be appalled if they saw how Manju leaned against her friend, or learned that the two girls shared a sky-blue sari (p. 183) Meena prefers to kill herself by taking rat poison. ‘this was one decision about her life she got to make’ (p.188).
 
Her death is commented on:‘“She was fed up with what the world had to offer,” the Tamil women concluded.  Meena’s family, upon consideration, decided that Manju’s modern influence was to blame’ (p. 189)The Tamil women understand.  Her family, like many voices following the Delhi rape, prefer to blame her - her brother beat her when he learned she had taken poison – and modern influence.
 
Yet there is also grim comedy to be found in the way other women are seen.  Abdul is embarrassed by his mother, Zehrunisa:‘Abdul believed his mother to be right about most things.  She was tender and playful with her children, and her only great flaw, in the opinion of Abdul, her eldest son, was the language she used when haggling.  Although profane bargaining was the norm in the waste business, he felt his mother acceded to that norm with too much relish; “Stupid pimp with the brain of a lemon!” she’d say in mock outrage.  “You think my babies will go hungry without your cans?  I ought to take down your pants and slice off what little is inside!”  This, from a woman who’d been raised in some nowhere of a village to be burqa-clad, devout.’(loc. 123)
 
The book gives us a deeper understanding of caste, rural versus urban, the relations between Hindus and Muslims and how all these can be manipulated.  These can be seen as structural, societal issues.  A more personal moral question raised during the book group meeting was: how it is possible for a man injured by the roadside to be left for hours without anyone attempting to help him? We see that some will not touch him for fear of catching a disease; others, like Zehrunisa taking essential items to her husband in prison across the city, are simply too desperate themselves to be able to stop.  What would we do? Boo writes ‘In undercities governed by corruption, where exhausted people vie on scant terrain for very little, it is blistering hard to be good.  The astonishment is that some people are good, and that many people try to be.’ (p.254)
 
One abiding poetic image that remained with us from the book was Abdul’s: ‘Water and ice were made of the same thing.  He thought that most people were made of the same thing, too . . .But here was the interesting thing.  Ice was distinct from – and in his view, better than – what it was made of.  He wanted to be better than what he was made of.  In Mumbai’s dirty water, he wanted to be ice.  He wanted to have ideals.  For self-interested reasons, one of the ideals he most wanted to have was a belief in the possibility of justice’. (p.218)
 

Comments

xiaozhengm

2015-6-16 xiaozhengm

tory burch shoes

coach outlet online

fitflops outlet

oakley sunglasses

burberry scarf

gucci outlet

true religion

gucci outlet online

michael kors bag

oakley sunglasses outlet

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet

kate spade bags

michael kors

chanel outlet

oakley sunglasses sale

gucci uk

true religion outlet

christian louboutin sale

ralph lauren

ray ban sunglass

tory burch handbags

pandora jewelry

tory burch outlet

coach outlet store online

chanel handbags

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

replica watches

christian louboutin outlet

ralph lauren uk

coach outlet online

air max 95

toms outlet

ray ban sunglasses

mont blanc pens

coach factory outlet

michael kors handbag

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

hollister clothing

oakley sunglasses

true religion outlet

kate spade outlet

ray bans

michael kors uk

nike air max

oakley sunglasses wholesale

abercrombie outlet

gucci outlet

coach outlet

pandora charms

cheap jerseys

michael kors

ray ban uk

ralph lauren outlet

prada outlet

hollister clothing store

cheap oakley sunglasses

burberry outlet

true religion sale

tory burch outlet online

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

michael kors bags

coach factory outlet

air max 90

coach factory outlet

kate spade handbags

burberry sale

oakley sunglass

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ray ban outlet

oakley sunglasses

burberry handbags

kate spade outlet online

chanel bags

jordan shoes

fitflops sale clearance

kate spade

rolex watches

michael kors outlet

soccer jerseys

coach outlet store online

burberry outlet online

pandora outlet

toms shoes

ray ban glasses

cheap jordans

true religion jeans

chanel online shop

cheap oakleys

kate spade uk

coach outlet

abercrombie

polo ralph lauren

Cheap Michael Kors Appears

Cheap Michael Kors Appears somewhat strange: Very first, Trainer weakening due to the fact Kors catch from using it http://www.comt.ca/mk.html generally there plenty of share of the market; next, Mentor is increasing to product lines, primarily with regard to article of clothing, so cheap michael kors outlet hoping to receive advancement; At the same time, Erika Kors really anticipate to mature in neuro-scientific michael kors outlet uk clothes. Eventually, "Mode Meeting Information" can also be talked about, Mentor Michael Kors Canada appointed a brand new custom made, looking to turnaround for the sword picture. Remorseful Michael kors Bags allies, when a brand started to be attainable, and is overexposed, and that means you Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet don't need to discover also need to see, and so basically this task went down hill michael kors handbags canada in the first place, and it is no way to get returning. Thus, now you can Cheap Stuart Weitzman Shoes rich person this particular discussion, with others AuthenticLouis Vuitton Outlet Sale indicatingMichael Kors Sale wait to see, Erina Kors continues to be unpopular friends, then you Louis Vuitton outlet need to have been legitimate. Have been obsessive about dressmaker Erina Kors design of the particular 1950s Michael Kors Purse from the very last one hundred year, the city continues to enhance the shape the picture with the gal in the nineteen fifties. This year, the particular Gucci Cheap Handbags Cheap Gucci Sale model is constantly on the pressure, lower from the selection of perspectives page Cheap michael kors handbags outlet form, impression, technological innovation Authentic Michael kors Purse and many others., revisit the actual 50's in the summertime, metropolis young lady model elongated Stuart weitzman shoes to everyone aspects of lifestyle, specifically in the beautiful recourse affectionate trend, this specific to help awaken remembrances Michael kors Outlet of your respective primary amatory trip Air Jordan 1 Retro wanting to light that is most complete high-class gals breeze perfect Louis Vuitton Bags present. "It turned out a wonderful Jordans for sale, Cheap jordans for sale free shipping period unbelievable, depends upon can be retrieving", Erika Kors claimed, which means this season's Michael Christian Louboutin Online series that individuals can easily be shifted Louis Vuitton Handbags with this loving 60's feeling, even as we with ease Authentic Louis Vuitton Canada Sale on the indicate really feel it - net ball bouquets Gucci online showing optimism as well as Michael Kors Discount strength. As a result, quite a few peculiarly chosen architect louis vuitton bags flowery images in addition to embellishment component, be it iii-perspective Louis Vuitton Neverfull Handbags crystalline organza dress daisies, uncomplicated Authentic Louis Vuitton Handbags shape attire geraniums, camellias or even unfastened bloomers, and even bouquets stitched ribbons within the dame Louis Vuitton Sale These are generally doubtless this exclusive fashion Louis Vuitton Outlet Sale female Michael kors cheap romantic factors. Developing, Erina Kors try and spotlight Louis Vuitton Purses a lady's shank outlines as well, do a little unaffixed Wholesale Electronics instead of tight shaping design and style, both equally healthy Stuart Weitzman Sandals, Cheap Stuart Weitzman Sandals on sale and just the right spot to attract the cloths line, passing out from your sense involving Louis vuitton cyber monday sale silent seems of an upsurge. It's wholesale Jordans well worth talking about could be that the architect specifically the use of shade for you to beige, khaki primarily Christian louboutin Outlet to be able to thrust the full series of semblance, done the favorable days of the past Air Jordan 1 shoes connected with the sun's rays any old style tactile property. Nonetheless, the azure shade and also white and black can be distributed Gucci Outlet Online together with Retro 3 considerable joys with this string exhibited model. This developer LV handbags Erika Kors has taken you an entirely new costume inspiration Cheap gucci handbags navy blue forked-breasted coating using stripy clothing and shorts, navy blue jacket crown Air Jordan 3 Cheap together with stitched plants organza dress, various sort of refreshing as well as calm wholesale Louis Vuitton store gown. Each time a brand's achievements louis vuitton outlet can also be inseparable via open public star Michael Kors handbags celeb with the "subscribe to" an upswing of Stuart weitzman boots sale Eileen Louis vuitton outlet manufacturer isn't exception Miranda Kerr, Freida Pinto, Gao Yuanyuan, such as a community Carina celebrities are usually brand name recommends, in addition to Christian Louboutin Cheap Us all Very first Dame Mrs . President obama Stuart Weitzman Boots with the Stuart weitzman 5050 Whitened Home dinner party using Michael Kors costume is company spotlight Cheap Stuart Weitzman Sale and not using a minute or even a pair of. Even though this relieve cheap michael kors will be Discount Michael kors UK Jordan Kors 2014 autumn and winter series, yet held AAir jordans 4 retro press conference to begin from the summer months, but it is away from Singapore to be able to sense burst. This is because the particular developer Erina Kors 1 fourth Stuart Weitzman 5050 ongoing your 2014 summer compilation of light-weight, real Stuart Weitzman On Sale put on designing, this informal atmosphere Retro Jordans 5 involving Colorado tend to be shot in the individual, inside the getting together with place, prominent Tv set rematch fly-by Cheap Stuart Weitzman Sale much more broadcast involving "Florida Dreams" of sunshine Michael Kors Uk audio and sizzling holiday New Jordans Sale air match Singapore! In the key serial sometimes appears a number of Cheap Jordans 11 textured fabrics, thick knitting sweater Authentic Jordan shoes 11 gradient coloring michael kors Handbags UK flannel, python synthetic leather, sequins as well as chiffon. Nevertheless tulle, clear fabrics, chest style http://www.sunglass1930.com/ remains to be Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet, Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags On Hot Sale putting into action the actual brand's graceful, sophisticated setting. Frailty-collection series is definitely cool Retro jordans 6 tactile property a tad bit more comfortable, unlike shades regarding camouflage clothing Michael Kors Outlet models Louis Vuitton Bags Fake for this concentration. Course Authentic Louis Vuitton Factory Outlet Online Store components listed wear shoes and book bag Authentic Jordans 10 is quite astonishing, without a doubt include the ideal mixture of lavishness Louis Vuitton Outlet, Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Sale in addition to street atmosphere. If you prefer a precise modeling method Michael kors Bags Cheap autumn temper, and then we've got to non Louis Vuitton bags skip Eileen Kors ahead of time fall 2014 can easily Michael kors cheap collecting. Scorching Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet picture burst open in the avenue to the character style Michael Kors factoryevening dress graceful evening meal, coming from wearing to work OL favor using the 100 test Louis vuitton Damier Ebene Canvas fatigue university winding, Erina Kors forces you to Wholesale Michael Kors satisfied. Erika Kors 2014 first autumn collection, of course, hardheaded and elegant, possibly the court docket Louis Vuitton online in 2010 with some stylus, including those people big prow Louis Vuitton Australia scarf, including those complex Replica Louis Vuitton Handbags Baroque prints, asymmetrical mantle fur Louis Vuitton Handbags Australia nevertheless it retains a really large general combination coefficient Rely on Replica Louis Vuitton Coach, Corporation. Trainer Michael Kors Outlet talk about eating away and also contrast, Michael Kors Hodlings Ltd. has become one with the hottest increasing quickly recently "lighting luxury" brand Michael Kors Outlet Store Online when the ii go hand in hand inside Grouping, right after making the most of comparison "results" Michael Kors improvement in it is share price into a Michael Kors Outlet Online new most of $ 101 immediately after comparing far more are generally aware to never repeat a similar mistakes Erina Kors Mentor Instructor. Not too long ago, The Wall Avenue Journal Wall structure Street Newspaper "Read About the Road" pillar had been printed fret Erina Kors in the sales channel may possibly measure Trainer Trainer actions and also effect model information creating Michael Kors Hodlings Ltd. shares fell into three.fladskrrrm percentage on Saturday to help $ eighty five.67 Thursday, this inventory plunged seven.35 % in order to a lot more $ 79.xliv. WSJ's chromatography column main matter Erika Kors list design, fearing the wholesale and also low cost gross sales portion connected with hefty, thus sacrificing power over the actual {brand|manufacturer|brand name|model|company|sword